Shopping at LEGO or Amazon?
Please use our links: LEGO.comAmazon
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

PPP and PPW

Vindic8edVindic8ed Member Posts: 197
edited March 17 in Buying & Selling Topics
While reading the comments in the Land Rover announcement, alternative measurements for value was talked about (as it has been in the past).  I didn't look to see if anyone has done calculations for PPW and posted them here, but I decided to do some quick ones.  I liked the idea of using the average weight/price per piece as the value of the set.  I grabbed the entire modular range and came up with this:

Name Released Price Weight (grams) Pieces PPW PPP PPW-PPP Average
Green Grocer 2008 149.99 3180 2335 0.047 0.064 0.056
Police Station 2021 199.99 4155 2903 0.048 0.069 0.059
Grand Emporium 2010 149.99 2903 2154 0.052 0.070 0.061
Fire Brigade 2009 149.99 2761 2215 0.054 0.068 0.061
Cafe Corner 2007 139.99 2591 2044 0.054 0.068 0.061
Pet Shop 2011 149.99 2820 2154 0.053 0.070 0.061
Palace Cinema 2013 149.99 2770 2170 0.054 0.069 0.062
Market Street 2007 89.99 1780 1236 0.051 0.073 0.062
Town Hall 2012 199.99 3825 2733 0.052 0.073 0.063
Parisan Restaurant 2014 159.99 2610 2449 0.061 0.065 0.063
Downtown Diner  2018 169.99 2800 2454 0.061 0.069 0.065
Detectives Office 2015 159.99 2624 2238 0.061 0.071 0.066
Brick Bank 2016 169.99 2745 2360 0.062 0.072 0.067
Jazz Club 2023 229.99 3870 2866 0.059 0.080 0.070
Assembly Square 2017 299.99 4666 3966 0.064 0.076 0.070
Botique Hotel 2022 229.99 3473 3037 0.066 0.076 0.071
Corner Garage 2019 199.99 3035 2545 0.066 0.079 0.072
Book Shop 2020 199.99 2932 2483 0.068 0.081 0.074
Modular Lego Store 2022 179.99 2440 2149 0.074 0.084 0.079
Modular Construction Site 2023 319.99 ? 3371 ? 0.095 ?

Note 1: the weights are from Bricklink; I'm not sure if the weights are the plastic themselves or if they include the box/instructions/packaging material

Note 2: The table is sorted by the last column (PPW-PPP Average)
560HeliportBumblepantsvizzitor

Comments

  • Vindic8edVindic8ed Member Posts: 197
    I know there are a lot of ways people have come up with to value a set.  PPP/PPW may still not be the best measurement of value, but I liked the suggestion of combining several metrics together.  By doing that we could come up with a universal way of comparing sets' values.
    560HeliportBrickchap
  • HuwHuw Administrator Posts: 7,075
    BrickLink weights are of the sealed box, used for shipping purposes. 25% of it is usually accounted for by the manual.

    Vindic8ed560Heliport
  • BrainsluggedBrainslugged Member Posts: 2,199
    Are those weights from Bricklink? I'd always wondered if the weights given are weight of the entire package (inc box, manual etc) or the weight of just the bricks.
  • Vindic8edVindic8ed Member Posts: 197
    edited March 17
    Thanks Huw, that's good to know.  I have all the modulars; I'm thinking of weighing just the builds, but none of them are built atm...so it will take some time to do.  I'd also like to compare similarly priced sets to other themes to get a better dataset.

    Would it be safe to assume that 30-35% of the sealed box weight does not contribute to the set?
    560Heliport
  • 560Heliport560Heliport Member Posts: 3,724
    @Vindic8ed I believe Bricklink's weights are for the boxed set: packaging, instructions, and parts, because the item's dimensions are listed below the weight, and they're clearly the box dimensions.
    FWIW, PPP and PPW are meaningless for me. I assess the value of a set by how much I like the model, including minifigs, new/rare parts or colors, play features. This is entirely subjective, of course! 
    Vindic8ed
  • iwybsiwybs Member Posts: 363
    Bricklink has separate weights for the box and for the instructions. Subtract those and you'll be left with the weight of the parts and the plastic bags.
    560HeliportVindic8ed
  • 560Heliport560Heliport Member Posts: 3,724
    @iwybs Thank you, I didn't know that! I mostly use Bricklink just for the part inventories.
  • Vindic8edVindic8ed Member Posts: 197
    I assess the value of a set by how much I like the model.
    As subjective as that is, that's honestly the best way to look at any set. However, I feel like it's a good idea to have a solid baseline of how far your money is going.
    560Heliportoldtodd33
  • Vindic8edVindic8ed Member Posts: 197
    edited March 17
    iwybs said:
    Bricklink has separate weights for the box and for the instructions. Subtract those and you'll be left with the weight of the parts and the plastic bags.
    That's cool, thank you!

    Using the Jazz Club as an example, ~27% of the weight is the box/instructions. 

    After thinking about it a little more, I'm hesitant to take those out of the calculation though as they contribute to the cost of the set.  It could be argued one way that they don't add value to the actual playability of the set; it could be argued the other way, that it helps a set retainis value.  Maybe include both, "Overall PPW" and "Brick PPW".
  • vizzitorvizzitor Member Posts: 480
    edited March 17
    To compare each properly, you'd also have to account for inflation. Especially as somehow it's 16 years (sixteen!) since 2007, the earliest on the list.
    560Heliportickis
  • ickisickis Member Posts: 3
    vizzitor said:
    To compare each properly, you'd also have to account for inflation. Especially as somehow it's 16 years (sixteen!) since 2007, the earliest on the list.
    I forgot all about inflation.  That's a good point.  I still think both these metrics don't do much to account for premiums on complex parts and printed parts.
  • oldtodd33oldtodd33 Member Posts: 2,678
    vizzitor said:
    To compare each properly, you'd also have to account for inflation. Especially as somehow it's 16 years (sixteen!) since 2007, the earliest on the list.
       No, the whole reason for the list is so you can see the inflation. For example, Green Grocer PPP is .064 and the latest Jazz Club is .080. If you adjust for inflation you would never see this. PPW is useless/pointless knowledge since it includes the weight of the box, manual and empty plastic bags which don't add anything of visual value to the actual set. 
  • 560Heliport560Heliport Member Posts: 3,724
    oldtodd33 said:
    vizzitor said:
    To compare each properly, you'd also have to account for inflation. Especially as somehow it's 16 years (sixteen!) since 2007, the earliest on the list.
       No, the whole reason for the list is so you can see the inflation. For example, Green Grocer PPP is .064 and the latest Jazz Club is .080. If you adjust for inflation you would never see this. PPW is useless/pointless knowledge since it includes the weight of the box, manual and empty plastic bags which don't add anything of visual value to the actual set. 
    No, if you don't adjust for inflation, then Green Grocer has the better PPP. But you can't buy Green Grocer new today for $149.99!
  • oldtodd33oldtodd33 Member Posts: 2,678
    oldtodd33 said:
    vizzitor said:
    To compare each properly, you'd also have to account for inflation. Especially as somehow it's 16 years (sixteen!) since 2007, the earliest on the list.
       No, the whole reason for the list is so you can see the inflation. For example, Green Grocer PPP is .064 and the latest Jazz Club is .080. If you adjust for inflation you would never see this. PPW is useless/pointless knowledge since it includes the weight of the box, manual and empty plastic bags which don't add anything of visual value to the actual set. 
    No, if you don't adjust for inflation, then Green Grocer has the better PPP. But you can't buy Green Grocer new today for $149.99!
       Doesn't matter that I can't buy a new GG, I'm not looking to. The point is to see inflation and adjusting for it wipes that out, some call it disinformation. This isn't the US government.
  • Vindic8edVindic8ed Member Posts: 197
    ickis said:
    I forgot all about inflation.  That's a good point.  I still think both these metrics don't do much to account for premiums on complex parts and printed parts.
    I don't feel like the Modulars have very many complex and/or printed parts.  Most of the ones that have printed parts can be found in other sets.  One that immediately comes to mind is the sailboat tile.
  • Vindic8edVindic8ed Member Posts: 197
    oldtodd33 said:
    PPW is useless/pointless knowledge since it includes the weight of the box, manual and empty plastic bags which don't add anything of visual value to the actual set. 
    Calculating it out doesn't seem to be a huge issue though, since we have the weights of the box and manuals.  One example already mentioned is the Jazz Club.  Those two items account for ~27% of the weight; take out another 3-5% for the plastic bags and it should be relatively close to the actual weight of the pieces themselves.  I haven't had a chance to look at all the numbers but I should have some time to do it tomorrow.
  • Vindic8edVindic8ed Member Posts: 197
    edited March 19
    No, if you don't adjust for inflation, then Green Grocer has the better PPP. But you can't buy Green Grocer new today for $149.99!
    I will add inflation to the chart as an additional category so people can see the differences.  However, in the case of the Green Grocer, the PPP would be worse, since it's adjusted price today is $217.49 (not taking into account that it's not available): .094 PPP.
  • oldtodd33oldtodd33 Member Posts: 2,678
    Vindic8ed said:
    No, if you don't adjust for inflation, then Green Grocer has the better PPP. But you can't buy Green Grocer new today for $149.99!
    I will add inflation to the chart as an additional category so people can see the differences.  However, in the case of the Green Grocer, the PPP would be worse, since it's adjusted price today is $217.49 (not taking into account that it's not available): .094 PPP.
       That was my whole point. Adjusting for inflation lies about the price. If left alone it shows GG was cheaper which of course it was. Inflation has caused the price of each brick to increase by 1.6 cents not drop down 1.4 cents. That's the lie. Lies, damned lies and statistics. 
    Vindic8ed
  • BrickchapBrickchap Member Posts: 1,261
    Thank you for posting this! I like this idea and agree combining measurements is a good way of getting an idea of price value. (as long as people don't treat it as the Word of God it's fine).
    Personally I like Jangbricks 'Amount of Stuff That You Get', especially when judging play sets and sets aimed at kids. For example the 2015 Deep Sea Research Vessel I think it was called was excellent value. You got a floating ship with a crane, multiple submarines, a bunch of sea creatures, and a whole ship wreck (also with a gold story that could easily tie in to other themes like Police or Cargo). Compare that to other sets around $100 where you'd get a big police station for example but kids can't actually do all that much with it. (I would also mention if you have multiple children then play sets with lots of stuff are also often better value).
    Another example would be the 2017 Airshow (2 jets plus a biplane plus a hangar and tug) for I believe it was around $70 compared to $150 for one giant plane that only fits 6 passengers (and doesnt even come with that many minifigs), too large to store easily or fit in an airport layout, large and bulky for a kid to fly around lots of prefabricated pieces so difficult to rebuild into something else.
    Or that new backhoe set for $30 compared to the new Indiana Jones fighter plane chase. Naturally a child's interests will determine buying decisions, but a cool car and fighter plane that shoots stuff with 3 minifigs is much better value than just one backhoe with 1 minifig with various issues regarding how the bucket and rear drill work.
    Vindic8ediwybs
  • Vindic8edVindic8ed Member Posts: 197
    oldtodd33 said:
    Vindic8ed said:
    No, if you don't adjust for inflation, then Green Grocer has the better PPP. But you can't buy Green Grocer new today for $149.99!
    I will add inflation to the chart as an additional category so people can see the differences.  However, in the case of the Green Grocer, the PPP would be worse, since it's adjusted price today is $217.49 (not taking into account that it's not available): .094 PPP.
       That was my whole point. Adjusting for inflation lies about the price. If left alone it shows GG was cheaper which of course it was. Inflation has caused the price of each brick to increase by 1.6 cents not drop down 1.4 cents. That's the lie. Lies, damned lies and statistics. 
    Not adjusting for inflation also shows the outliers, and how arbitrary pricing can be.  One of the newer sets, the police station, appears to be one of the best deals.
    Brickchap
  • oldtodd33oldtodd33 Member Posts: 2,678
    ^ Why is Police station an outlier? At .069 each and the average price of a modular being .067 each over the years it's just above average. I did not include the last two modulars as they are not official Lego sets and the last set isn't finalized for pieces or price.
    Brickchap
  • 560Heliport560Heliport Member Posts: 3,724
    edited March 20
    @Brickchap If you're going to compare sets, please get your facts straight. 
    2016's #60103 Airport Air Show was $119.99 AU$, #60104 Airport Passenger Terminal was $149.99 and did include six minifigures. So $120 vs. $150, not $70 vs. $150.
    This year's #60385 Construction Digger is $32.99 AU$ and includes two figures. #77012 Fighter Plane Chase is $49.99 nd includes three figures.
  • BrickchapBrickchap Member Posts: 1,261
    @560Heliport Okay so I confused the Yank price for the Aussie one. Airport Air Show is still much better value. Also, while yes Passenger Terminal does have 6 minifigs, that's all airport staff, the pilot, ground crew and passengers. You should get at least 5 regular civilian passengers. And the problems with the plane remain.
    Okay and for 60385 and 77012 well how do the Yank prices compare?
  • BrickchapBrickchap Member Posts: 1,261
    @Vindic8ed Yeah Police Station is great value. Sadly Boutique Hotel, but particularly Jazz Club are terrible value. I mean, just look at Police Station ($300 AU) compared to Jazz Club ($350 AU). Police Station is one of the taller, more imposing modulars, while JC is one of the shortest. To my knowledge people were pretty happy with Police Station (aside from the absence of any form of police vehicle was is rather silly) whereas Jazz Club from what I've read and seen 99% of people find it to be very 'meh'/underwhelming/disappointing etc. It's interesting too that even more controversial modulars like Downtown Diner had lots of people who really liked it, or at least certain parts of it, whereas Jazz Club it's not that anyone is saying it's terrible but there doesn't seem to be much anyone really likes about it. Police Station had lots of fun details and wasn't really lacking anything, whereas Jazz Club the pizzeria is barely as detailed as a City or Friends set (some Friends sets actually outdo it) while the rest of the building is pretty lacking or underwhelming with detail.
  • 560Heliport560Heliport Member Posts: 3,724
    @Brickchap #60385 is $19.99 and #77012 is $34.99. So #60385 is a slightly better value, relative to #77012, in the U.S. compared to Australia.
    I dislike "price points"- it means compromises must be made to hit e.g. $19.99. The designers either have to add some little side build or omit something else to make the perceived value come in at $19.99. I'd much prefer it if all the $19.99 sets actually got priced at their "true" price: one might be $18.63, another $21.84. 
    Brickchap
  • Vindic8edVindic8ed Member Posts: 197
    oldtodd33 said:
    ^ Why is Police station an outlier? At .069 each and the average price of a modular being .067 each over the years it's just above average. I did not include the last two modulars as they are not official Lego sets and the last set isn't finalized for pieces or price.
    I was using the PPW/PPP calculation, not just the PPP.  I'll be posting the updated chart below, which deducts the weight of the box/instructions.
  • Vindic8edVindic8ed Member Posts: 197
    edited March 20
    New chart:

    Name Price PPP PPW TPPW TPPW/PPP PPW/PPP
    Green Grocer 149.99 0.064 0.069 0.047 0.056 0.067
    Police Station 199.99 0.069 0.066 0.048 0.059 0.068
    Cafe Corner 139.99 0.068 0.067 0.054 0.061 0.068
    Market Street 89.99 0.073 0.065 0.051 0.062 0.069
    Grand Emporium 149.99 0.070 0.070 0.052 0.061 0.070
    Town Hall 199.99 0.073 0.068 0.052 0.063 0.071
    Fire Brigade 149.99 0.068 0.074 0.054 0.061 0.071
    Pet Shop 149.99 0.070 0.072 0.053 0.062 0.071
    Palace Cinema 149.99 0.069 0.073 0.054 0.062 0.071
    Parisan Restaurant 159.99 0.065 0.083 0.061 0.063 0.074
    Downtown Diner  169.99 0.069 0.085 0.061 0.065 0.077
    Detectives Office 159.99 0.071 0.084 0.061 0.066 0.078
    Brick Bank 169.99 0.072 0.083 0.062 0.067 0.078
    Jazz Club 229.99 0.080 0.082 0.059 0.070 0.081
    Assembly Square 299.99 0.076 0.087 0.064 0.070 0.082
    Modular Lego Store 179.99 0.084 ? 0.074 0.079 0.084
    Botique Hotel 229.99 0.076 0.094 0.066 0.071 0.085
    Corner Garage 199.99 0.079 0.092 0.066 0.073 0.086
    Book Shop 199.99 0.081 0.092 0.068 0.075 0.087
    Modular Construction Site 319.99 0.095 ? ? 0.095 0.095
    Average 184.99 0.074 0.070 0.055 0.067 0.076

    Note1: Chart is sorted by PPW/PPP (last column)
    Note2: TPPW = Total Price Per Weight (set, box, instructions) vs. PPW (just the set)

    Notice that--for the most part--PPW and PPP are relatively close.  There are a few outliers, like Detective's Office and Brick Bank.
  • Vindic8edVindic8ed Member Posts: 197
    edited March 20
    You're not able to sort the data from the chart here on the forums, but if you put it into Excel and sort by the different categories there are some interesting trends (again, with some outliers).

    For example, taking the TPPW, the cheapest set has the lowest weight and the most expensive set has the highest weight:
    Market Street 2007 89.99 1780
    Assembly Square 2017 299.99 4666

    Two of the outliers are:
    Downtown Diner  2018 169.99 2800
    Green Grocer 2008 149.99 3180

    There are a couple changes when sorting by PPW but it's place in the chart is relatively consistent to TPPW (IE, Assembly Square is still the most and Market Street still the least).  I believe weight has a significant role to play in price point (at least in this data I've gathered for the modulars).

    This does not take into account inflation, but I think that makes this even more interesting, because the prices have remained relatively the same (if not arguably low) if you are looking at the weight alone.  Sets that have more material cost more and sets that have less cost less).
Sign In or Register to comment.

Shopping at LEGO.com or Amazon?

Please use our links: LEGO.com Amazon

Recent discussions Categories Privacy Policy Brickset.com

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Brickset.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, the Amazon.com.ca, Inc. Associates Program and the Amazon EU Associates Programme, which are affiliate advertising programs designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.